Wednesday 22 March 2023 \


The difference between miracles, karamahs and magic.

Prophet Muhammadﷺ showed unbelievers of Mecca the splitting of the moon.

By Aisha Stacey / 4 Feb 2013

Islam defines a miracle as an extraordinary act or event that is contrary to the laws of nature and can only come about through the direct intervention of Allah Almighty Himself.  The Arabic word for miracle is mu’jizah.  It stems from the word ajz, meaning something that incapacitates, cannot be resisted, unique.  According to Islam, miracles are performed by the permission of Allah, by the prophets of Allah.  Miracles are not magic, which is by definition a trick or illusion, nor is a miracle an event brought about by a learned righteous people who are not prophets of Allah.  These events are called karamahs.  Thus we find three distinct categories, miracles, karamahs and magic.

Allah sent the prophets and messengers primarily to guide humankind.  They were humans, of outstanding character, pious and trustworthy, that the people could emulate and look to for direction.  They were not gods, demi-gods or saints with divine qualities, rather they were mere mortals charged with a difficult task.  They possessed exceptional characteristics because they were obligated to face extraordinary trials and tribulations in order to spread the message to worship Allah Alone. 

“And I (Allah) created not the jinn  and mankind except that they should worship Me (Alone)”.  (Quran 51:56)

In order to make each prophet credible in his particular time and place, Allah granted them miracles, pertinent, relevant and understandable to the people to whom they were sent.  In the time of Moses magic and sorcery were prevalent therefore Moses’ miracles appealed to the people he was sent to guide.  In the time of Holy Prophet Muhammad , the Arabs, although predominantly illiterate, were masters of the spoken word.Their poetry and prose were considered outstanding and a model of literary excellence.The miracle that defined Prophet Solomon (peace be upon him) was his unique kingdom. At the time of Jesus, the Israelites were very knowledgeable in the field of medicine. Consequently, the miracles Jesus performed were of this nature and included returning sight to the blind, healing lepers and raising the dead.  

“And you heal those born blind and the lepers by My leave.   And behold!  You bring forth the dead by My leave.”(Quran 5:10)

A karamah is an extraordinary matter or event that is brought about at the hands of a believer who obeys Allah, refrains from sin and whose piety is recognised as being at a very high level. Unlike a miracle which is meant to be done openly and be known by the people so that they would recognize the truthfulness of the prophets, a karamah usually only benefits the one to whom it is given. A karamah could include such things as knowledge, power or something astonishing such as the angels in a cloud of light that shaded Usayd ibn al-Hudayr, one of Prophet Muhammad’s companions, when he recited Quran (Saheeh Al-Bukhari).  A karamah also occurred for Maryam, the mother of Prophet Jesus.

So her Lord accepted her with goodly acceptance.  He made her grow in a good manner and put her under the care of Zakariya . Every time he entered her praying place, he found her supplied with sustenance.  He (peace be upon him) said: “O Maryam (Mary)!  From where have you got this?”  She said, “This is from God.  Verily, God provides sustenance to whom He wills, without limit.” (Quran 3:37)

A miracle results in nothing but good and is given by the Almighty to the Prophets as a sign.  This is coupled with a life of exemplary morals and character, and a message of goodness.  Magic can also bring about something extraordinary; however no good can come from magic.  It is performed by evil people and is done by seeking the help of the devils and drawing close to them.  Miracles cannot be learnt or undone, whereas magic can be learnt, cancelled out or undone.

Prophet Moses’ encounter with the magicians at Pharaoh’s court explains the difference between magic and miracles.

They said, "O Moses, either you throw [your staff], or we will be the ones to throw [first]. He said, "Throw," and when they threw, they bewitched the eyes of the people and struck terror into them, and they presented a great [feat of] magic. And We inspired to Moses, "Throw your staff," and at once it devoured what they were falsifying. So the truth was established, and abolished was what they were doing. And Pharaoh and his people were overcome right there and became debased. And the magicians fell down in prostration [to Allah ]".(Quran 7:115-120)

The magicians understood that Moses (peace be upon him) was not performing a trick or illusion as they had done.  They understood deception well and knew that Moses actions were a miracle.  Thus they accepted the truth and fell down in prostration to Allah, knowing full well that it would bring about their death for disobeying Pharaoh.  

Miraclescan be of two types; those that occur at the suggestion of the people the miracles are supposed to impress or convince and those that occur without suggestion from the people.  An example of the first type is when Prophet Saleh’s (peace be upon him) people suggested he bring out from behind the mountain a she camel and her offspring.  When the unbelievers in Mecca asked the Prophet Muhammadto show them a miracle, he showed them the splitting of the moon.  One of Prophet Muhammad’scompanions mentioned this event saying, “We were with God’s Messenger at Mina, when the moon was split in two parts.  One part was behind the mountain and the other one was on this side of the mountain.  God’s Messenger said to us, “Bear witness to this” (Saheeh Muslim)

An example of the second type is what happened when the tree trunk cried and longed for Prophet Muhammad.  He, the Prophet used to give his Friday speech while leaning on a palm tree.  One of his followers suggested they make a minbar for him but the next Friday when the Prophet climbed onto the minbar the tree trunk started moaning and crying for him like a child. 

Muslims believe that the Quran itself is a miracle.  Prophet Muhammad said, “Every Prophet was given miracles because of which people believed, but what I have been given is divine inspiration which Allah has revealed to me, so I hope that my followers will outnumber the followers of the other Prophets on Resurrection Day.” (Saheeh Al-Bukhari)

Prophet Muhammadwas implying that the Quran itself is the greatest miracle of all time; it is a miraculous book filled with miracles of all kinds.  Its revelation, literary excellence, and its content, including scientific, prophetic and historical information, all contribute to Quran’s status as a miracle.


We recommend

Social Networks